Only 10% of time on trains used ‘productively’ by business travellers

Not as productive as HS2 opponents think?

Just 10% of time spent on trains is used ‘productively’ by business travellers, according to research commissioned by the Department for Transport (Sept 30). Click here.

These findings won’t please opponents to HS2 who have claimed in the media and during the Transport Select Committee hearings that workers can be just as productive on trains as in the office.

The report (prepared by consultancy Oxera) concluded that only a tenth of time was spent productively, with many travellers reading for leisure, surfing the internet or enjoying the view.

HS2 opponents have already been claiming online that this undermines the business case for High Speed Rail.

Not only is this a complete about turn in their argument, it’s also incorrect.

If people aren’t working productively while travelling it is even more important they reach their destinations quickly.

HS2 opponents frequently claim there will be less demand as internet use (and remote working) increases.

This is anecdotal and based on assumptions. Evidence states that, if anything, the internet is encouraging travel.

The West Coast Main Line is increasingly busy with passenger demand rising at 6% per year and the highest number of passengers on the network since the 1920s.

We are increasingly free to roam and work where we choose.

Debate has raged around time savings with HS2, with critics suggesting a saving of 20-25 minutes between Birmingham and London (although they mischievously and incorrectly claim 10 minutes) is irrelevant.

Twenty to twenty five minutes is, of course, considerable, but what critics don’t like to talk about are the time savings heading north from the West Midlands.

This isn’t unusual – there is a great deal of cherry-picking when it comes to debating HS2 – critics will refer to £34bn (total Y-network cost) when they really mean £17bn (Birmingham to London cost).

They will also say HS1 in Kent is not used by enough passengers, but when its excellent record of recycling 95% of spoil locally is quoted they complain that it’s an unfair and misleading comparison.

So, if critics want to suggest 20-25 minutes saved between the capital and Second City isn’t good enough they could perhaps acknowledge the tremendous savings between our other major cities. Because HS2 is not just about London.

Birmingham to Leeds is cut from around 2h 5m to around one hour

Birmingham to Manchester is cut from 1h 40m to less than 50m

We don’t apologise for signing off with capacity. Time is important, but we’ve always said the greatest reward HS2 brings to the West Midlands is the release in capacity.

This allows us to increase local, regional and freight services as well as putting us firmly at the centre of a new railway network linking us with cities across the UK and Europe.

This entry was posted in Economic and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Only 10% of time on trains used ‘productively’ by business travellers

  1. nick says:

    there is one train in one direction only that currently does london birmingham in 72 minutes. all others are scheduled for 83 to 85 minutes. hs2 with one stop is scheduled to take 49 minutes. so about 35 minutes. all trains to points further north that use hs2 will save 35 minutes. london – manchester will be also considerably less journey time wise. for those whose say that this is only a small savings, or who question the need to reduce journey times need only take a motorway journey at 7O mph and see how many cars pass them ! and speed isnt even the main benefit of hs2, it it the capacity it both provides and releases on the classic lines.

    As far as this article goes, I think it is safe to say that train travellers may well read or relax or work on the train but that is because the journeys take longer then they need to ! they may take the train because they can do these things but it isnt the reason they are travelling. It is also hard to do any of these things standing up ! but you cant do any of these things when driving even if some idiots try to !.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s